BlogGuide
Cold DM vs cold email for B2B: how to use both on one list
Cold DM vs cold email for B2B: who reads each channel, what to send in each, and a three-week sequence that runs Instagram, email and LinkedIn on one list.
By Jakub Kowalski, Founder
Cold DM or cold email: use both, and start with the cold DM. With small businesses, the DM opens the conversation on Instagram with a short question, the email carries the offer in writing, and LinkedIn, where the owner has a profile, repeats your name. Put all three on one list, one row per business, send the steps a few days apart, and end the sequence in every channel when the person replies in any of them. In DM Hero, the cold DMs and follow-ups go out from your own Instagram account, and a reply there stops that person's remaining steps.
A cold email is the first email to a person or a company you have had no contact with before. A cold DM is the same first message, sent as a direct message on Instagram. When you sell to small businesses, what matters more than the format is who reads each one and what each one is good for.
Who reads each channel and what to send
| Instagram DM | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Who reads it | Whoever answers the business's Instagram messages | Whoever handles the address: the owner, someone in the office, or a shared inbox such as contact@ | The owner, if they have a profile |
| First message | Two or three sentences: one detail about their business and one question | A subject line and a few sentences: why you are writing, what you offer, one question | A connection request without an offer |
| Follow-up | A short message in the same thread, with one new piece of information | A reply in the same email thread, with one new reason to answer | A short message after they accept |
| When they reply | Answer in the DM, then propose one next step | Answer by email and put the call or meeting in that reply | Answer in messages, or move to email if they ask |
In one sequence, each channel does a different job:
- The DM starts the conversation. It arrives in the business's Instagram inbox, and a short question is easy to answer there.
- The email carries the offer. Prices, a link to an example, something the owner can forward to a business partner: an email keeps them together in one message.
- LinkedIn repeats your name. Where the owner has a profile, a connection request without a pitch comes from the same person as the DM and the email.
For a list of small businesses, that gives a simple rule: Instagram goes first, and email and LinkedIn add to it.
What to prepare before the Instagram channel starts
The whole process, from the list to handing a conversation over, is in the Instagram cold outreach guide. Before a sequence in three channels, check four things:
- A profile that says who is writing. A prospect who wants to check the sender opens your profile. A bio that says what you do and for whom, and a few posts or highlights with your work, answer that before they ask. The same profile helps when someone writes to you first, and Outbound vs inbound on Instagram covers how the two directions work together.
- The Instagram account of every business. One column with the username or a link to the profile. DM Hero's importer reads either, and you pick which other columns to import.
- One detail per business, in its own column. For example a new menu, a second location, a full calendar in the stories. In DM Hero you tick that column at import and it becomes a custom field: a column called detail goes into the message as
{{custom.detail}}. A business whose cell is still empty waits for that step until you fill it in, so nobody gets a sentence with a gap. - A first message and two follow-ups written for Instagram. Shorter than the email, with one question each. There are examples in How to write a cold DM on Instagram, and the free cold DM generator puts a first message and two follow-ups together for you.
One list, three channels: a three-week sequence
Put each business in one row of a spreadsheet: name, Instagram handle, email address, the owner's LinkedIn profile if there is one, and one detail about the business. Then plan the steps of all three channels on one calendar:
Day 1: Instagram DM
One detail about the business and one question
Day 2: LinkedIn connection request
No offer
Day 4: email
The offer in writing, with a line about the DM
Day 8: Instagram follow-up
One new piece of information
Day 10: LinkedIn message
Only after they accept, two sentences
Day 15: last Instagram message
An easy question that closes the loop
Day 17: last email
A short close that leaves the door open
Why it is built this way:
- Instagram goes first. The email on day 4 then comes from someone whose name is already in the business's Instagram inbox.
- The email mentions the DM. One sentence is enough: "I also wrote to you on Instagram on Monday." The two channels read as one conversation, not two campaigns.
- No day carries two messages. The Instagram steps are a week apart, the emails go out on days 4 and 17, and LinkedIn takes days 2 and 10.
- Every step brings something new. The email on day 4 brings the details, the follow-up on day 8 an example, and the last messages an easy question that takes a yes or a no. What to write in each follow-up is in Instagram DM follow-ups.
In DM Hero, the Instagram part is one campaign with three steps and gaps of 0, 7 and 7 days. Each gap counts from the day the previous step went out, and you can set any gap from 0 to 90 days.
Stop after a reply in any channel
A reply in one channel ends the sequence in all of them. From that moment it is a conversation, and a scheduled email that lands after the prospect has already answered your DM reads as if nobody saw the answer.
- A reply on Instagram. DM Hero stops that person's remaining steps in every campaign and sets their status to replied. The CSV export in DM Hero's Analytics shows every lead's status and tags next to their Instagram handle, ready to match against your email list.
- A reply by email or on LinkedIn. In the campaign view, remove the person from the campaign or, if they said no, set their status to not interested. Leads marked converted or not interested drop out of the sending queue in every campaign.
- Continue where they replied. Someone who answered by email gets your answer by email, with the call or meeting in it. Someone who answered in the DM stays in the DM, even if your offer is in the email.
This is how it can look when the reply comes on Instagram after the email. A studio that builds websites with online booking writes to a barbershop that takes bookings only by phone:
Conversation with kestrel.cuts
You: Hi, saw you added a second chair in October, and your stories say November is almost fully booked. Booking is still by phone only in your bio. We build simple websites with online booking for barbershops. Want me to send 2 examples?
You: One more thing: the email I sent you on Thursday has an example from a two-chair shop like yours. Should I send the link here too?
Prospect: Saw the email, just didn't get to it. Send it here
You: Here you go: (link to the example). If it looks like something for you, in 15 minutes I'll show you how it would work with your hours and prices. Would you be open to a short call?
Prospect: Sure, next week works
You: Great, pick a time that suits you: (booking link)
The barber answered in the DM, so DM Hero stopped the last Instagram step and set the shop's status to replied, and the seller dropped the day 17 email. The follow-up mentioned the email, so the owner knew both messages came from the same person, and the booking link went out only after the "sure".
Measure per person
Three channels send more messages than one, so the number of messages tells you little. Count people:
- Reply rate per person: people who replied in any channel, divided by people who got the first message.
- Where the reply came from: the channel, and the step after which it came. That shows which step to rewrite first.
- What happened after the reply: a call booked, an offer sent, a no.
In DM Hero, a reply on Instagram sets the lead's status to replied on its own, and a booking through the Calendly link the AI Setter sends marks the lead converted and tags it booked, on a Calendly plan with webhooks. Tag the people who replied by email or on LinkedIn, for example email-reply and linkedin-reply, and the Analytics export gives you one file with every person, their status and their tags, ready to count. When you compare campaigns, templates or niches in DM Hero's Analytics, the denominator is people, not messages.
The Instagram steps in DM Hero
In DM Hero, the Instagram part of this sequence takes one import and one campaign: the three steps go out from your own Instagram account, and the replies land in the DM Hero inbox.
With the AI Setter on Autopilot, a prospect who replies gets an answer within minutes. The setter handles objections from your playbook and sends your booking link when the conversation gets there, and the prospect picks the time. When a prospect writes their email address or phone number in the DM, the setter passes the thread to you, and you continue by email or phone. The setup, step by step, is in How to set up an AI appointment setter for Instagram.
The AI Setter is part of the Starter, Growth, Pro, Pro multi-reps and Multi-client plans. Compare all plans on the pricing page, and on a demo we will set up the Instagram steps of your three-week sequence with you.
Frequently asked questions
- Is a cold DM or a cold email better for selling to small businesses?
- With small businesses, start with a cold DM on Instagram and add an email: the DM opens the conversation with a short question, and the email adds the details in writing. You can run both on one list and let the first reply decide where the conversation continues.
- Can you send cold DMs and cold emails to the same prospects?
- Yes. Keep one list with each business's Instagram handle, email address and, where there is one, the owner's LinkedIn profile. Plan the steps of every channel on one calendar, a few days apart and never two on the same day, and stop all remaining steps as soon as the person replies in any channel.
- What should you do when a prospect replies in one channel?
- Stop the remaining steps in every channel and continue in the one they replied in. Someone who answered by email gets your answer by email. Someone who answered on Instagram stays in the DM, and the emails still scheduled for them do not go out.
- How do you measure multichannel cold outreach?
- Per person, not per message: how many people on the list replied in any channel, in which channel the reply came and after which step. Then what happened next, such as a call booked or an offer sent. The share of people who replied can be compared between lists and sequences, the number of messages sent cannot.
- What tool runs the Instagram part of a multichannel sequence?
- DM Hero. You import the same list as a CSV file, a campaign sends the cold DMs and follow-ups from your own Instagram account at the gaps you set between steps, and a reply on Instagram stops that person's remaining steps. On Autopilot, the AI Setter answers replies within minutes and sends your booking link, and the prospect picks the time.
